Honey vs Capital One Shopping vs SimplyCodes vs PromoIQ
We tested these four coupon extensions, and Coupert, on the same 50 US online stores, twice, and counted only what the store's own checkout total showed. SimplyCodes saved the most. PromoIQ, which we make, saved the least with its own codes, and was the only one that sent nothing before the shopper clicked.
Tests run on October 10 and October 11, 2026, with a release candidate of PromoIQ 3.0. Coupert was in the same test; its results are on How we test. If something here is wrong or out of date, tell us and we will fix it.
October 19, 2026: Since this test, PromoIQ has changed how it finds codes; we will re-run the same test and update this page.
The short answer
- Most money saved: SimplyCodes. It lowered the checkout total at 22 stores in both runs ($220.94 each run), with no false claims and no affiliate links. Of these four, Capital One Shopping was second on dollars.
- Nothing sent before you click: PromoIQ. It made 0 network requests before the shopper clicked, at all 50 stores in both runs. Honey, Capital One Shopping and SimplyCodes made network requests before any click at every store they reached, and some of those requests included the store's web address.
- No affiliate links: PromoIQ and SimplyCodes. Neither showed any affiliate redirect, tab or cookie in our test. Capital One Shopping did in 20 and 21 of 50 runs, Honey in 3.
- Where PromoIQ is weak: with only the codes it found for each store, it saved less than all three, Honey included. With its "Also try common codes" option on, it lowered the total at 21 stores in both runs, against 10 for Honey, but still saved fewer dollars than Capital One Shopping and SimplyCodes.
The numbers
Run 1 / run 2. A saving counts only if the store's own total went down and stayed down after a page reload. PromoIQ is shown two ways: with only codes it found for that store, and with "Also try common codes" turned on (the panel marks each of those "A common code, not found for this store").
| PayPal Honey | Capital One Shopping | SimplyCodes | PromoIQ, store codes only | PromoIQ, plus common codes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stores reached (of 50) | 49 / 48 | 50 / 50 | 45 / 44 | 50 / 50 | 50 / 50 |
| Stores where the total truly dropped | 10 / 10 | 19 / 18 | 22 / 22 | 7 / 8 | 21 / 21 |
| Dollars saved, checked after reload | $95.52 / $95.52 | $186.11 / $174.82 | $220.94 / $220.94 | $61.84 / $67.03 | $160.91 / $166.75 |
| Savings claims that were false or too high | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 |
| Runs with affiliate redirects, tabs or cookies | 3 / 3 | 20 / 21 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
| Network requests the extension made before any click (median per store) | 70 / 70.5 | 87 / 88 | 39 / 40 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
| Site access asked for at install | All sites | All sites, plus tabs, cookies and web navigation | All sites | None (only the tab you click it on) | None (only the tab you click it on) |
Where the others beat PromoIQ
- Dollars saved. SimplyCodes ($220.94 in both runs) and Capital One Shopping ($186.11 and $174.82) saved more than PromoIQ in either setting ($166.75 at most).
- PromoIQ's own codes. With store codes only, PromoIQ lowered the total at 7 and 8 stores. Honey did at 10. PromoIQ's supply of codes for each store is still small.
- Getting the amount right. Honey, Capital One Shopping and SimplyCodes made no false or overstated claims. PromoIQ overstated one saving in each run: at Vuori a code really took $11.60 off and PromoIQ said $50.61, because it read the store's savings line as the new total. We fixed that before PromoIQ 3.0 was released, and it still counts against PromoIQ above.
- Rewards. Honey and Capital One Shopping offer rewards. PromoIQ has no cash back or rewards.
Where PromoIQ leads
- Nothing happens until you click. PromoIQ made 0 network requests before the click at all 50 stores in both runs. The others made network requests before any click at every store they reached (a median of 39 to 88 per store), and some of those requests included the store's web address.
- No affiliate links. PromoIQ sent shoppers through no affiliate link, tab or cookie in any of its 100 store visits per setting. SimplyCodes didn't either. Capital One Shopping's "Try Codes" opened or went through affiliate links in 20 and 21 runs, and Honey's "Apply Deals" also activated rewards in 3.
- Narrow permissions. PromoIQ asks for no site access when you add it. It reads only the tab you click it on. Honey and SimplyCodes ask for all sites; Capital One Shopping asks for all sites plus your tabs, cookies and web navigation.
- More stores than Honey, with common codes on. With "Also try common codes" turned on, PromoIQ lowered the checkout total at 21 of 50 stores in both runs, compared with 10 for Honey.
Each extension in one paragraph
PayPal Honey. Made no false claims, but lowered the total at only 10 of the stores it reached. It made network requests that included the store's web address before any click at every store it reached, and its popup asked shoppers to log in or sign up in 29 and 30 runs.
Capital One Shopping. Second on dollars saved and never overstated a saving (at 5 stores it showed less than the store did). Its "Try Codes" went through affiliate links in 20 and 21 runs, and in run 2 it applied a saving at two stores before any click.
SimplyCodes. Saved the most, made no false claims and showed no affiliate activity. It lists codes for you to use: in our test, a script pasted its listed codes the way a shopper would. Like Honey and Capital One Shopping, it made network requests that included the store's web address before any click, at every store it reached.
PromoIQ. Sent nothing before the click and used no affiliate links. With only the codes it found for each store, it saved the least. With common codes on, it saved at more stores than Honey, and fewer dollars than Capital One Shopping and SimplyCodes. It marks a code "worked" only after it saw the checkout total go down, and says so plainly when none of the codes it tried lowered the total.
What this test does not tell you
- Large retailers. Most large US retailers block automated browsers, and we did not try to get around that. At the 8 we could test, no extension lowered the total. The other 42 stores are smaller brands, mostly on Shopify.
- Whether an extension replaces someone else's referral. There was no earlier referral in our carts, so we could see affiliate links being added, not overwritten.
- Price comparison and cash back were not part of this test.
- One snapshot. One cart per store, one US location, two days, scripted browsing. Results at your stores can differ.
The full method, every rule we set before testing and the Coupert results are on How we test. For Honey alone, with its size, rewards and the news about it, see PromoIQ vs Honey. We plan to run the test again after each major update and post the numbers here, whatever they show.
Try PromoIQ at your next checkout
Click PromoIQ on a store's cart page and press "Try these codes for me." It enters one code at a time, reads your total and keeps the one that saves the most. If none lowers the total, it says so.